Car A
Volkswagen ID.3 1ST
The Volkswagen ID.3 1ST is a compact electric hatch that blends city-friendly size with usable range. Strong power and five-seat practicality make it a capable daily and small-family choice.
Volkswagen ID.3 1ST
Hatchback · Electric · FWD
vs
Mercedes-Benz AMG A 45
Hatchback · Gasoline · FWD
Car B
Mercedes-Benz AMG A 45
The Mercedes-Benz AMG A 45 is a compact, five-seat performance car that delivers 421 hp and a 3.9 s 0–100 km/h sprint while remaining usable with a 370 L trunk. It offers good value in its segment, though its FWD layout and modest cargo flexibility may limit winter and cargo-heavy use.
Why compared
same body typesame ranking profilesame seatsstrong ranking match
Usage fit
Family
54
/
53
City
56
/
52
Budget / value
31
/
37
Road trip
42
/
41
Performance
26
/
36
Cargo
21
/
20
Practical
28
/
36
Premium
27
/
55
Winter
26
/
26
Scores out of 100. Blue = Volkswagen ID.3 1ST · Orange = Mercedes-Benz AMG A 45
Specs side-by-side
Spec
Volkswagen ID.3 1ST
Mercedes-Benz AMG A 45
Values are representative — confirm for your market and trim.
Pros & cons
Volkswagen ID.3 1ST
- 420 km rated range supports commuting and occasional road trips
- Brisk 0–100 km/h in 7.3 s boosts confidence in urban traffic
- Five seats and a 385 L boot suit small-family needs
- Good value in its segment given 204 hp and a 58 kWh battery
- Not ideal for cargo-heavy use; 385 L limits bulky loads
- Performance drivers may find the 160 km/h top speed limiting
- Front-wheel drive may deter shoppers seeking AWD traction
- Price near 39,900 may stretch tighter budgets
Mercedes-Benz AMG A 45
- Explosive acceleration (0–100 km/h in 3.9 s).
- Five seats and a 370 L trunk support daily use.
- Efficient for its class at 8.2 L/100 km.
- Good value in its segment for a 421 hp compact.
- FWD may limit traction in harsh winter conditions.
- 370 L cargo space is modest for cargo-heavy needs.
- 8.2 L/100 km is higher than economy-focused compacts.
- Price around 55,000 can stretch tighter budgets.
Verdict
Pick Volkswagen ID.3 1ST if…
Lower entry price
Volkswagen ID.3 1ST starts lower, making it the stronger value pick if budget is a priority.
Pick Mercedes-Benz AMG A 45 if…
More power
Mercedes-Benz AMG A 45 puts out 421 hp vs 204 — meaningfully quicker and more confident on motorways.